Financial services have perhaps the largest cyber security budgets and are the best protected companies in the private sector. Since cyber criminals generally have little difficulty in obtaining a quick return on their effort, it would be unsurprising to find that financial services are less overtly targeted by average hackers than other, easier targets. At the same time, the data held by finserv is so attractive to criminals that it remains an attractive target for more sophisticated hackers.
Both premises are confirmed in a report (PDF) published this week by Vectra. From August 2017 through January 2018, Vectra's AI-based Cognito cyberattack-detection and threat-hunting platform monitored network traffic and collected metadata from more than 4.5 million devices and workloads from customer cloud, data center and enterprise environments.
An analysis of this data showed that financial services displayed fewer criminal C&C communication behaviors than the overall industry average. This could be caused by the efficiency of large finserv budgets (Bank of America spends $600 million annually, with no upper limit, while JPMorgan Chase spends $500 million annually) warding off basic criminal activity.
Even the much smaller Equifax has a budget of $85 million. But Equifax, with its massive 2017 loss of 145.5 million social security numbers, around 17.6 million drivers' license numbers, 20.3 million phone numbers, and 1.8 million email addresses, demonstrates that finserv is a target for, and can be successfully breached by, the more advanced hackers.
Vectra analyzed the Equifax breach and then compared the attack methodology to what its Cognito platform was finding in other financial services companies -- and it discovered the same breach methodology in other financial services firms. This is the use of hidden tunnels to hide the C&C servers and disguise the exfiltration of data.
Vectra's new analysis shows that the criminal use of hidden tunnels is far more widespread in financial services than in any other industry sector. Across all industries Vectra found 11 hidden exfiltration tunnels disguised as encrypted web traffic (HTTPS) for every 10,000 devices. In finserv, this number jumped to 23. Hidden HTTP tunnels jumped from seven per 10,000 devices to 16 in financial services.
Chris Morales, head of security analytics at Vectra, commented, "What stands out the most is the presence of hidden tunnels, which attackers use to evade strong access controls, firewalls and intrusion detection systems. The same hidden tunnels enable attackers to sneak out of networks, undetected, with stolen data."
"Hidden tunnels are difficult to detect," explains the report, "because communications are concealed within multiple connections that use normal, commonly-allowed protocols. For example, communications can be embedded as text in HTTP-GET requests, as well as in headers, cookies and other fields. The requests and responses are hidden among messages within the allowed protocol."
These hidden tunnels need to be protected at all times, says Will LaSala, director security solutions and security evangelist at OneSpan. "Many app developers put holes through firewalls to make services easier to access from their apps, but these same holes can be exploited by hackers. Using the proper development tools, app developers can properly encrypt and shape the data being passed through these holes."
One of the problems is that developers are rushed to implement a new feature to maintain or gain customers, "and this," he adds, "often leads to situations where a hidden tunnel is created and not secured."
Once a hidden tunnel is established by an attacker, it is almost impossible to detect with traditional security. There is no signature to detect while specially created C&C servers will unlikely show up on reputation lists. Furthermore, because the traffic using a hidden tunnel is ostensibly legitimate traffic, there is no clear anomaly for anomaly detection systems to detect.
What Vectra's analysis shows is that while there may be fewer overt attacks against financial services, the industry is a prime target for advanced hackers willing and able to invest in more covert attacks.